Landscape Architecture for Landscape Architects › Forums › GENERAL DISCUSSION › Drawing the line › Reply To: Drawing the line
Why should any well trained landscape architect feel intimidated by any profession? Is it really intimidation that you sense or is it something else altogether? What I mean is given the breadth of our profession, there is very little that we specialize in, yet we are proficient in so much. We literally are swimming in information on so many diverse areas of knowledge that it makes advocating for the profession so very difficult, especially in the presence of architects, urban designers and engineers, all of whom have very clear roles.
The beauty of Landscape Architecture is the nebulosity, but that is also its weakness.
Getting back to your original question, the difference between architecture and landscape architecture is quite simple to me, we live in architecture, we exist in the landscape.
If both professions are in and through each other made possible, should they be separated in word and meaning?
A few years ago a question like this would have been followed by a joint, a glass of red wine and a notepad that I was embarrassed to read the next day… At this moment, I like the fact that we don’t need to be separated in word, but our profession has a gorgeous word added: landscape. that explodes the scope of what we do, and to me, sounds elegant and confident: landscape architecture.
What is to stop the architect from learning to design a landscape? What is to stop the LA from designing a building?
If you ask them, they may say they already know how… just ‘shrub it up’. I’d respond by saying that anyone can design a building, all you need is a floor, four walls and roof…. since most architecture is really uninspiring, it gives me great confidence that it isn’t that hard to design a building. For example I have designed the home that I am going to build out of shipping containers one day… all i needed was time and sketchup.
Is it not possible for an LA to read, understand, contend with and practice architectural theory. I will contend that it is more than possible.
It is possible. A hobbyist can be a potent designer if they want… I have seen many gardeners whom put landscape architects to shame…
Landscape architects will determine for themselves how far they want to go?
Currently the economy is determining that for all of us…
