Reply To: The Case Against Mulch Rings: A few reasons you should stop circling trees with mulch

Landscape Architecture for Landscape Architects › Forums › PLANTS & HORTICULTURE › The Case Against Mulch Rings: A few reasons you should stop circling trees with mulch › Reply To: The Case Against Mulch Rings: A few reasons you should stop circling trees with mulch

#165443
Andrew Garulay, RLA
Participant

There is a clear difference between a “mulch ring” and a “mulch volcanoe”. I don’t think anyone defends mulching against a trunk. The article is on mulch rings in general. There is a time and a place for a properly maintained mulch area around a tree that is surrounded by turf.

In fact there are times when someone may choose the wimsy of a goofy looking swiss cheese look. You and I may not appreciate it, but it does not make it inherently wrong.

Some landscapes are a little too much for Joe’s Lawn Care (JLC) to properly maintain, but it does not mean that the intent is for JLC to set foot on the property.

If one designs for properties that JLC is going to maintain then it is absolutely poor design to present a condition that is destined to failure.

There are plenty of folks out there that would consider the turf to be the wrong element in the provided picture. I, for one, would not have a universal condemnation for turf either – neither would I have a universal acceptance of it.

Everything is situational. When we assume criteria to judge a design, we may be inventing circumstances that do not apply.

Lost Password

Register